Hungary: legal requirements and validity of electronic signatures

Is eSignature legal in Hungary? This article explores the key aspects of electronic signature legality in Hungary, including the relevant laws, standards, and conditions, as well as recent developments and industry-specific requirements.

Legal signature requirements in Hungary: understanding the basics

Electronic signatures in Hungary are primarily regulated by Act CCXXII of 2015 on the general rules for electronic administration and trust services and the eIDAS Regulation (EU Regulation No 910/2014 on electronic identification and trust services for electronic transactions in the internal market). These laws ensure that electronic signatures are legally recognised and binding, provided certain conditions are met.

1. Act CCXXII of 2015: The primary legislation governing electronic signatures in Hungary is Act CCXXII of 2015 on the general rules of electronic administration and trust services. This law implements the EU's eIDAS Regulation (Regulation (EU) No 910/2014) on electronic identification and trust services for electronic transactions in the internal market. It provides a comprehensive framework for the use and legal recognition of electronic signatures in Hungary. It defines different types of electronic signatures and their legal effects, ensuring that they can be used in various transactions and legal proceedings. You can find the full text of the Act here. 
2. eIDAS Regulation (Regulation (EU) No 910/2014): The eIDAS Regulation is an EU-wide regulation that applies directly in Hungary and other EU member states. It aims to facilitate cross-border electronic transactions by providing a uniform legal framework for electronic identification and trust services. It establishes three types of electronic signatures: simple electronic signatures, advanced electronic signatures, and qualified electronic signatures. Each type offers different levels of security and legal assurance, with qualified electronic signatures providing the highest level of legal certainty. You can find the full text of the Regulation here. 

These laws establish the legal validity of electronic signatures in Hungary and set out the conditions under which they are considered equivalent to traditional handwritten signatures. They provide that electronic signatures cannot be denied legal effect and admissibility as evidence in legal proceedings solely on the grounds that they are in electronic form.

Electronic signatures in Hungary: types and legal standing

The law recognises different types of electronic signatures, each with varying levels of legal weight:

1. Simple electronic signatures: The most basic form of electronic signatures, offering the lowest level of security. While these are considered valid for many everyday transactions, they may not be sufficient for high-value or legally sensitive documents.
2. Advanced electronic signatures: Provide a higher level of security, are uniquely linked to the signatory, and are capable of identifying the signatory. They are more secure than simple electronic signatures.
3. Qualified electronic signatures: These are created using a qualified electronic signature creation device and are based on a qualified certificate. They offer the highest level of security and legal certainty, and are equivalent to handwritten signatures in all EU member states.

Electronic signature law in Hungary: standards and conditions

For an electronic signature to be legally binding in Hungary, it must meet certain standards and conditions. These include:

1. Intention: The signatory must have the intention to sign the document electronically.
2. Consent: All parties involved must consent to conduct business electronically.
3. Identification: The signatory must be uniquely identifiable, especially for advanced and qualified electronic signatures.
4. Authentication: The electronic signature must be capable of verifying the signatory's identity.
5. Control: The method used to create the electronic signature must be under the sole control of the signatory.
6. Association with the document: The electronic signature must be logically associated with the document, ensuring that any subsequent changes to the document are detectable.
7. Integrity: The signed document must remain unchanged and tamper-proof. 

For qualified electronic signatures, which offer the highest level of security and legal assurance, the following additional requirements must be met:

8. Use of qualified electronic signature creation devices: Qualified electronic signatures require the use of a qualified signature creation device, which is a secure tool for creating electronic signatures.
9. Qualified certificate issued by a qualified trust service provider (QTSP): The signature must be based on a qualified certificate for electronic signatures issued by a qualified trust service provider.

Qualified electronic signatures which meet additional technical and legal requirements are given the same legal effect as traditional “wet ink” signatures in Hungary and are automatically considered authentic in legal proceedings.

Interested in exploring digital workflows for your contracts? Hit the button below to get in touch and find out more.

Find out more about eSignature laws in Eastern Europe:

• Legal requirements for eSignature in Croatia
• Legal requirements for eSignature in Cyprus
• Legal requirements for eSignature in Czechia
• Legal requirements for eSignature in Estonia
• Legal requirements for eSignature in Latvia
• Legal requirements for eSignature in Lithuania
• Legal requirements for eSignature in Poland
• Legal requirements for eSignature in Romania
• Legal requirements for eSignature in Slovakia
• Legal requirements for eSignature in Ukraine

Electronic signature in Hungary: limitations and exceptions

While electronic signatures are widely accepted in Hungary, there are some circumstances where they may not be valid or may have limitations:

1. Lack of consent: If the signatory did not intend to sign the document electronically.
2. Technical failures: Issues with the signature creation device or software can render the signature invalid.
3. Non-compliance with standards: Failure to meet the required standards for advanced or qualified electronic signatures.
4. Documents requiring notarization: Some legal documents, such as real estate transactions, may still require a notary's physical signature and seal.
5. Wills and testaments: Hungarian law currently does not allow for electronic signatures on wills.
6. Family law documents: Certain family law documents, like marriage certificates or adoption papers, may require traditional signatures.
7. High-value financial transactions: Some financial institutions may require additional verification for large transactions, even with a qualified electronic signature.

It's important to note that these limitations are subject to change as laws and regulations evolve to accommodate digital transformation.

Recent court decisions on electronic signature in Hungary

To date, there have not been significant court rulings in Hungary that specifically question the validity of electronic signatures. This stability is largely attributed to the robust legal framework established by Act CCXXII, which is in harmony with EU regulations governing electronic signatures. The clarity and consistency of these regulations have thus far mitigated legal challenges in this area.

Nonetheless, legal professionals in Hungary remain vigilant, closely monitoring developments in European Union case law, as any significant rulings at the EU level could potentially impact the interpretation and application of electronic signature laws within Hungary. This ongoing scrutiny ensures that Hungary's legal stance on electronic signatures remains aligned with broader European legal trends, maintaining both legal certainty and compliance with international standards.

Forthcoming legislation on electronic signatures in Hungary

At present, there are no significant legislative changes anticipated that would alter the landscape of electronic signatures in Hungary. The existing legal framework, anchored by the eIDAS Regulation and Act CCXXII, provides a comprehensive and stable foundation for the use of electronic signatures, ensuring their validity and enforceability in both domestic and cross-border transactions.

However, as a member of the European Union, Hungary is expected to integrate any future EU-wide regulations or directives concerning electronic signatures and trust services into its legal framework. This alignment with EU initiatives is crucial, as it ensures that Hungary remains consistent with broader European standards, facilitating interoperability and mutual recognition of electronic signatures across member states. Such integration not only supports seamless cross-border transactions but also enhances the trust and security associated with electronic signatures within the region.

Moreover, Hungary’s legal and regulatory bodies, along with industry professionals, are closely monitoring ongoing developments in EU legislation and case law related to electronic signatures and digital trust services. This vigilance is essential for anticipating and preparing for any necessary adjustments to national laws or practices, thereby ensuring continuous compliance with evolving European regulations. As digital transformation accelerates and new technologies emerge, Hungary’s proactive stance in this area positions it to effectively navigate and adapt to any forthcoming changes in the electronic signature landscape, both at the national and EU levels.

Industry-specific standards for electronic signatures in Hungary

While the general framework for electronic signatures applies across all industries in Hungary, certain sectors have specific requirements or preferences:

1. Financial services: Many financial institutions require advanced or qualified electronic signatures for high-value transactions or loan agreements. For instance, the Hungarian National Bank (MNB) requires the use of qualified electronic signatures for high-value transactions and regulatory filings.
2. Healthcare: The healthcare sector often uses advanced or qualified electronic signatures for patient records and prescriptions. Additionally, electronic signatures must comply with strict data protection standards, especially when handling sensitive patient information.
3. Legal services:  Law firms often use advanced or qualified electronic signatures for client agreements and court filings to ensure authenticity and confidentiality.
4. Real estate: While many documents in real estate transactions can be signed electronically, some still require traditional signatures or notarization.
5. Public administration: Government agencies increasingly accept and use electronic signatures for various administrative procedures.

Adoption of electronic signatures in Hungary

The adoption of electronic signatures in Hungary is steadily increasing, driven by digital transformation efforts across various sectors. Key factors contributing to the widespread adoption include:

• Cost efficiency: Electronic signatures reduce the need for physical paperwork, lowering costs for businesses.
• Convenience: The ability to sign documents remotely enhances operational efficiency and customer satisfaction.
• Security: Advanced and qualified electronic signatures offer robust security measures, mitigating the risk of fraud.
• Legal recognition: The clear legal framework ensures businesses and individuals have confidence in using electronic signatures.

Leading providers of electronic signature services in Hungary

Several providers offer electronic signature solutions in Hungary, catering to diverse business needs. Some of leading providers include:

1. DocuSign: A global leader in electronic signature solutions.
2. Juro: A popular contract automation platform known for its user-friendly interface and robust security features, Juro is a popular choice for businesses of all sizes.
3. Adobe Sign: Part of the Adobe Document Cloud suite.
4. SignRequest: Offers a user-friendly platform suitable for small to medium-sized businesses.
5. HelloSign: A Dropbox company providing electronic signature solutions.
6. Scrive: Specialises in electronic signature and identification solutions for various industries.
7. Yousign: A European electronic signature solution.
8. Eversign: Provides a user-friendly platform with features suitable for various industries.

These providers offer a range of features, from basic electronic signatures to advanced and qualified solutions, catering to different industries and compliance requirements.

FAQ: common questions about electronic signatures in Hungary

Are electronic signatures legally binding in Hungary?

Yes, electronic signatures are legally binding in Hungary, provided they meet the requirements set by Act CCXXII of 2015 and the eIDAS Regulation.

What is the difference between advanced and qualified electronic signatures?

Advanced electronic signatures offer a higher level of security than basic electronic signatures, while qualified electronic signatures provide the highest level of security and are equivalent to handwritten signatures.

Can I use an electronic signature for all types of documents in Hungary?

While electronic signatures are widely accepted, some documents (like wills or certain notarized documents) may still require traditional handwritten signatures.

Do I need special software to create an electronic signature in Hungary?

For simple electronic signatures, you may not need special software. However, for advanced or qualified signatures, you'll need to use a trusted service provider.

How can I ensure my electronic signature is legally valid?

To ensure legal validity, use a reputable eSignature provider that complies with eIDAS standards, and verify the signatory's identity and intent.

How can I verify an electronic signature in Hungary?

Qualified electronic signatures can be verified through the certificate issued by a qualified trust service provider. Many eSignature platforms also offer built-in verification tools.

Are there specific industries in Hungary that require advanced or qualified electronic signatures?

Yes, industries like financial services, legal services and healthcare often require advanced or qualified electronic signatures due to higher security and compliance requirements.

Is there a difference between electronic signatures in Hungary and other EU countries?

The eIDAS Regulation provides a uniform framework across the EU, so electronic signature standards are consistent in Hungary and other member states.

Are electronic signatures from other EU countries valid in Hungary?

Yes, under the eIDAS Regulation, electronic signatures from any EU country are recognised across all member states, including Hungary.

What are the benefits of using electronic signatures in Hungary?

Electronic signatures offer cost savings, convenience, enhanced security, and legal recognition, making them an efficient choice for businesses and individuals.

What happens if an electronic signature is challenged in court?

If challenged, the court will evaluate whether the electronic signature meets legal requirements, such as identification, consent, and compliance with standards, to determine its validity.

How can I stay updated on changes in electronic signature laws in Hungary?

Regularly check updates from the Hungarian government, EU regulations, and trusted legal sources to stay informed about any changes in electronic signature laws and standards.

How can I choose the right electronic signature provider in Hungary?

Consider factors such as security features, ease of use, compliance with industry standards, integration capabilities, and customer support when choosing an electronic signature provider.

Who are the leading providers of electronic signatures in Hungary?

Leading providers include Juro, DocuSign, Adobe Sign, and SignRequest, offering a range of solutions to meet various needs.

--

Electronic signatures in Hungary are legally recognised and widely adopted across various sectors. The legal framework, supported by Act CCXXII of 2015 and the eIDAS Regulation, provides a solid foundation for the use of electronic signatures, ensuring they are as legally binding as traditional handwritten signatures. With the ongoing digital transformation and the convenience offered by electronic signatures, we can expect to see even more widespread use of electronic signatures across various sectors in Hungary.

Juro is not a law firm and this article should not be relied on as legal advice.