France: legal requirements and validity of electronic signatures

This article sets out the legality, requirements, and adoption of electronic signatures in France.

Main laws determining the legality and binding status of electronic signatures in France

The legal framework for electronic signatures in France is primarily governed by European Union regulations and French national laws. The main legislative instruments include:

1. eIDAS Regulation (EU Regulation No. 910/2014): The electronic identification and trust services for electronic transactions in the internal market (eIDAS) is a comprehensive EU regulation that establishes the standards for electronic identification and trust services, including electronic signatures. It is directly applicable in all EU member states, including France. eIDAS provides a legal framework for electronic signatures, ensuring they have the same legal standing as traditional “wet ink” signatures under certain conditions. It sets out three types of electronic signatures, which include:

• Simple electronic signature: Basic electronic data used to sign documents.
• Advanced electronic signature: Requires a higher level of security, ensuring the signature is uniquely linked to the signatory, capable of identifying them, and attached to the data in such a way that any changes can be detected.
• Qualified electronic signature: This is the highest standard, equivalent to a handwritten signature. It must be created using a qualified electronic signature creation device and based on a qualified certificate issued by a trusted service provider.

You can find the full text of the regulation here. 

2. French Civil Code (Code Civil): Articles 1366 and 1367 of the French Civil Code recognize the legal validity of electronic signatures, provided they fulfil certain criteria. An electronic signature must use a reliable identification process that guarantees the signatory's identity and their consent to the document. You can find the full text of the code here. 
3. French Law No. 2000-230 of 13 March 2000 adapting the right of evidence to information technology and relating to electronic signature: This law, also known as the “Electronic Signature Law,” was one of the first to recognize the legal equivalence of electronic and handwritten signatures, which is now codified in Articles 1366 and 1367 of the French Civil Code. It set the foundation for further regulations and was integrated into the eIDAS framework. You can find the law here. 
4. French Decree No. 2017-1416 of 28 September 2017 on electronic signature: This decree outlines the conditions under which electronic signatures are presumed to be reliable, further supporting the eIDAS requirements. You can find the decree here. 

These laws work together to establish the validity and enforceability of electronic signatures in France.

Relevant standards and conditions for legally binding electronic signatures in France

To ensure that an electronic signature is legally binding in France, certain standards and conditions must be met:

1. Unique link to the signatory: The signature must be uniquely linked to the signatory and capable of identifying them.
2. Control by the signatory: The means of creating the signature must be under the sole control of the signatory.
3. Integrity of signed data: Any alteration to the signed data must be detectable, ensuring the document's integrity is maintained.
4. Legal intention: The signatory must have a clear intention to sign the document, and this intention should be verifiable.

For qualified electronic signatures, which offer the highest level of security and legal assurance, the following additional requirements must be met:

5. Use of qualified electronic signature creation devices: The signature must be created using a device that complies with EU standards.
6. Qualified trust service providers (QTSPs): The signature must be based on a qualified certificate issued by a recognised QTSP. 

Qualified electronic signatures are considered legally equivalent to handwritten signatures in France and across the EU.

Electronic signature law in France: validity and limitations

While electronic signatures are widely accepted in France, there are certain circumstances where they may not be valid or may require additional formalities:

1. Failure to meet technical standards: If the electronic signature does not meet the standards outlined under eIDAS, it may not be considered valid.
2. Insufficient identification of the signatory: If the signature does not provide sufficient identification of the signatory, it may be challenged in court.
3. Alteration of the document: If there is evidence that the document has been altered after signing without detection, the signature may be invalidated.
4. Specific legal requirements: Certain documents, such as those related to family law, wills, real estate transactions and court documents, may still require handwritten signatures under French law.
5. Absence of consent: If it can be proven that the signatory did not consent to the electronic signature, its validity may be disputed.

Interested in exploring digital workflows for your contracts? Hit the button below to get i touch and find out more.

Recent court decisions on electronic signatures in France

French courts have generally upheld the validity of electronic signatures when they meet the legal requirements.

However, specific cases have helped clarify certain aspects of eSignature law. For instance, in a judgement delivered on March 13, 2024, the Court of Cassation (highest court in the French judiciary) held that a scanned signature does not identify its author and does not prove his consent to the obligations arising from the signed act. You can read the judgement here.

This decision underscores the importance of using proper electronic signature technologies that can ensure the integrity of the document and the identity of the signatory.

Forthcoming legislation on electronic signatures in France

Currently, there are no significant legislative changes anticipated specifically regarding electronic signatures in France. However, ongoing discussions at the EU level may influence future updates to eIDAS, potentially impacting national laws.

The European Commission has been exploring the integration of new technologies like blockchain and AI into the eIDAS framework, which could enhance the security and usability of electronic signatures. France, like other EU member states, is focusing on implementing the eIDAS 2.0 Regulation, which aims to improve cross-border recognition of electronic identities and further streamline digital transactions.

Additionally, as technology continues to evolve, the French government is keeping pace with changes in electronic signature regulations to enhance the legal framework for electronic signatures in the country.

Industry-specific standards for electronic signatures in France

While the general standards for electronic signatures apply across industries, certain sectors have additional requirements:

1. Financial services: The Autorité des Marchés Financiers (AMF) requires that electronic signatures used in financial transactions adhere to the highest standards of security and authenticity. This often involves the use of qualified or advanced electronic signatures.
2. Healthcare: The French healthcare sector mandates strict compliance with data protection regulations. Electronic signatures in this industry must ensure patient confidentiality and data integrity.
3. Real estate: While some real estate transactions still require handwritten signatures, there's a growing trend towards using qualified electronic signatures for certain documents.
4. Government services: Many government agencies in France now accept electronic signatures for various administrative procedures, often requiring advanced or qualified signatures. Electronic signatures used in government contracts must comply with additional security protocols to ensure data integrity and authenticity.

Adoption of electronic signatures in France

The adoption of electronic signatures in France has been steadily increasing, driven by digital transformation initiatives across various sectors. The COVID-19 pandemic has further accelerated this trend, as remote work and digital transactions have become more prevalent, with more businesses and individuals turning to digital solutions. Key factors contributing to this growth include: 

• Government initiatives: The French government has been promoting the use of electronic signatures to streamline administrative processes and reduce paperwork.
• Business adoption: Many French businesses have integrated electronic signatures into their operations, particularly in legal, financial, and administrative processes.
• Consumer acceptance: Many French consumers are comfortable using electronic signatures for personal transactions, such as banking and insurance.

Leading providers of electronic signatures in France

Several companies provide electronic signature solutions in France, offering a range of services to meet different needs. Some of the leading providers include:

1. DocuSign: A global leader in electronic signature solutions.
2. Juro: A popular contract automation platform known for its user-friendly interface and robust security features, Juro is a top choice for many businesses.
3. Adobe Sign: Part of the Adobe Document Cloud suite.
4. Yousign: A European electronic signature solution.
5. Scrive:Offers electronic signature solutions with features for contract management.
6. Eversign: Provides a user-friendly platform with features suitable for various industries.

These providers offer a range of solutions, from simple electronic signatures to qualified electronic signatures that meet the highest legal standards in France and the EU.

FAQ: common questions about electronic signatures in France

Are electronic signatures legally binding in France?

Yes, electronic signatures are legally binding in France, provided they meet the requirements set out in the French Civil Code and the eIDAS Regulation.

What types of electronic signatures are recognized in France?

France recognises three types of electronic signatures: simple electronic signatures, advanced electronic signatures, and qualified electronic signatures. Each type has different levels of security and legal recognition.

Do I need a special device to create a valid electronic signature?

For simple and advanced electronic signatures, no special device is required. However, qualified electronic signatures must be created using a qualified electronic signature creation device.

Can I use an electronic signature for all types of contracts in France?

While electronic signatures are valid for most contracts, some documents (like those related to family law or certain real estate transactions) may still require handwritten signatures.

What are the security requirements for electronic signatures in France?

To ensure legal validity, electronic signatures must meet specific security requirements, including unique identification of the signatory, data integrity, and compliance with eIDAS standards for advanced and qualified electronic signatures.

How can I verify the authenticity of an electronic signature in France?

Most electronic signature providers offer verification tools. For qualified electronic signatures, you can check the EU Trusted List to verify the signature's certificate.

Are there industry-specific requirements for electronic signatures in France?

Yes, certain industries, such as finance, healthcare, and government, may have additional requirements for electronic signatures to ensure data protection and compliance with sector-specific regulations.

How widely are electronic signatures used in France?

Electronic signatures are widely used in France, with many businesses adopting them for various processes. The government also promotes their use to streamline administrative tasks and reduce paperwork.

Are electronic signatures from other EU countries recognised in France?

Yes, thanks to the eIDAS Regulation, electronic signatures that meet EU standards are recognised across all member states, including France.

Are there any forthcoming changes in electronic signature legislation in France?

Currently, no significant changes are anticipated specifically for electronic signatures in France. However, ongoing developments at the EU level may influence future updates to eIDAS, potentially affecting national laws.

What are the benefits of using electronic signatures in France?

Electronic signatures offer numerous benefits, including increased efficiency, reduced costs, enhanced security, and improved compliance with legal and regulatory requirements.

Who are the leading providers of electronic signature services in France? 

Leading providers include Juro, DocuSign, Adobe Sign, Yousign, and others, offering diverse solutions for businesses and individuals.

--

Electronic signatures have gained widespread acceptance and legal recognition in France. As technology continues to evolve and digital transformation accelerates, we can expect to see even broader adoption of electronic signatures across various sectors of the French economy.

With the right tools and knowledge, electronic signatures can streamline processes, enhance security, and foster innovation in the digital age.

Juro is not a law firm and this article should not be relied on as legal advice.