Germany: legal requirements and validity of electronic signatures

This article explores the main laws, standards, conditions, and usage of electronic signatures in Germany, providing a detailed overview of the legal landscape and recommended providers.

Main laws governing electronic signatures in Germany

The legal framework for electronic signatures in Germany is primarily governed by European Union regulations and German national laws. The main legislative instruments include:

1. eIDAS Regulation (Regulation (EU) No 910/2014): This regulation provides a unified approach to electronic identification and trust services across the European Union, ensuring that electronic signatures have the same legal status as handwritten signatures. The eIDAS Regulation is a cornerstone of electronic signature law in Germany, defining three types of electronic signatures: 

• Simple electronic signature (SES)
• Advanced electronic signature (AES)
• Qualified electronic signature (QES)

Each type has different levels of security and legal weight. QES is considered equivalent to a handwritten signature and is legally binding across the EU. You can find the full text of the regulation here. 

2. The German Civil Code (Bürgerliches Gesetzbuch, BGB): The BGB includes provisions that recognise electronic signatures as legally binding, provided they meet specific requirements outlined in the eIDAS Regulation. You can find the full text of the code here. 
3. The Trust Services Act (Vertrauensdienstegesetz, VDG): This German law complements the eIDAS Regulation, focusing on the certification and regulation of trust service providers. It outlines the requirements for electronic signatures, seals, and time stamps, ensuring compliance with EU standards. You can find the full text of the Act here. 

These laws collectively establish the framework for electronic signature use and recognition in Germany.

Relevant standards and conditions for legally binding electronic signatures in Germany

To ensure that an electronic signature is legally binding in Germany, certain standards and conditions must be met:

1. Identification of signatory: The signature must uniquely identify the signatory.
2. Authentication: The signature must be attributable to the signatory.
3. Consent and intent to sign: All parties involved must agree to use electronic signatures and the signatory must have the intention to sign the document. 
4. Integrity of signed data: Any alteration to the signed data must be detectable, ensuring the document's integrity is maintained.
5. User control: The signatory must have sole control over the electronic signature creation data.
6. Compliance with eIDAS Regulation: The signature must fall into one of the three categories defined by eIDAS.

For qualified electronic signatures, which offer the highest level of security and legal assurance, the following additional requirements must be met:

7. Use of qualified electronic signature creation devices: Qualified electronic signatures require the use of a qualified signature creation device, which is a secure tool for creating electronic signatures.
8. Qualified trust service providers (QTSPs): The signature must be issued by a certified trust service provider recognized by the EU.

Qualified electronic signatures are considered legally equivalent to traditional “wet ink” signatures in Germany and across the EU.

Interested in exploring digital workflows for your contracts? Hit the button below to get in touch and find out more.

Electronic signature law in Germany: limitations and exceptions

Despite the robust legal framework supporting electronic signatures, certain circumstances may render an electronic signature invalid in Germany:

1. Lack of consent: If the signatory did not explicitly consent to the electronic signature process, the signature might be considered invalid.
2. Inadequate security measures: If the signature process lacks sufficient security measures, such as encryption or authentication, it may not be legally binding.
3. Non-compliance with QES requirements: For contracts requiring a QES, failure to use a qualified electronic signature creation device or a qualified trust service provider can invalidate the signature.
4. Specific legal exclusions: Certain legal documents, such as wills, family law documents,  or official documents requiring notarization may require handwritten signatures and exclude electronic signatures.
5. Industry-specific regulations: Some industries may have specific regulations that dictate the use of electronic signatures, and non-compliance with these regulations can lead to invalidity.

Recent court decisions on electronic signatures in Germany

German courts have generally upheld the validity of electronic signatures when they comply with legal requirements. However, specific cases have clarified certain aspects of electronic signature law in Germany. For example, in a judgement delivered on September 28, 2021, the Berlin Labor Court (Arbeitsgericht Berlin - ArbG Berlin) determined that a contract in electronic form did not meet the required standard of a qualified electronic signature (QES). The court confirmed that electronic signatures are permissible for employment contracts, provided they meet the QES requirements.

You can read the judgement here. This decision highlights the importance of using proper electronic signature technologies that ensure the integrity of the document and the identity of the signatory.

Forthcoming legislation on electronic signatures in Germany

Currently, there are no significant legislative changes specifically anticipated for electronic signatures in Germany. However, ongoing discussions at the EU level may lead to future updates to the eIDAS regulation, which could impact national laws. The European Commission has been exploring integrating new technologies like blockchain and AI into the eIDAS framework to enhance the security and usability of electronic signatures. Germany, as an EU member state, is actively working on implementing the eIDAS 2.0 Regulation which aims to improve cross-border recognition of electronic identities and further streamline digital transactions across the EU.

This initiative seeks to establish a more robust and secure digital identity infrastructure, making it easier for individuals and businesses to engage in digital activities seamlessly across borders. Additionally, as technology continues to evolve, the German government is committed to updating its electronic signature regulations to enhance the legal framework for electronic signatures. This includes ongoing evaluations of how emerging technologies can be leveraged to ensure that electronic signatures remain secure, efficient, and widely accepted in various sectors, such as finance, healthcare, and public administration.

The government is also working closely with industry stakeholders to develop guidelines and standards that support the adoption of innovative electronic signature solutions while maintaining compliance with legal requirements.

Industry-specific standards for electronic signatures in Germany

While the general standards for electronic signatures apply across industries, certain sectors have additional requirements:

1. Financial services: The financial sector often requires advanced or qualified electronic signatures for high-value transactions and for compliance with anti-money laundering (AML) regulations. For instance, banks may use biometric authentication for advanced electronic signatures to ensure secure identity verification.
2. Healthcare: Electronic signatures in healthcare must comply with strict data protection regulations, such as GDPR, to protect patient information. Patient consent forms typically need advanced or qualified Electronic Signatures
3. Real estate: If electronic signatures are permitted in residential or commercial real estate transactions, then qualified electronic signatures are typically required to ensure the authenticity and integrity of contracts.
4. Legal services: Law firms often require qualified electronic signatures for legal documents, ensuring compliance with regulatory standards.
5. Government services: Government agencies require qualified electronic signatures for official documents and eGovernment services. 

Adoption of electronic signatures in Germany

Electronic signatures have gained significant traction in Germany, driven by technological advancements and legal recognition. Several factors contribute to their widespread adoption:

1. Digital transformation: Businesses are increasingly digitising their operations, leading to a surge in the use of electronic signatures for various transactions.
2. Legal recognition: The eIDAS Regulation and German laws provide a solid legal foundation for electronic signatures, boosting confidence among businesses and consumers.
3. COVID-19 pandemic: The pandemic accelerated the adoption of electronic signatures, as remote work and contactless transactions became the norm.
4. Efficiency and cost savings: Electronic signatures offer significant time and cost savings compared to traditional paper-based processes, making them an attractive option for businesses.
5. Environmental impact: The use of electronic signatures reduces paper consumption, aligning with sustainability goals and environmental initiatives.

Leading providers of electronic signatures in Germany

Several companies provide electronic signature solutions in Germany, catering to businesses and consumers across various industries. Some of the leading providers include: 

1. DocuSign: A global leader in electronic signature solutions.
2. Juro: A popular contract automation platform known for its user-friendly interface and robust security features, Juro is a popular choice for businesses of all sizes.
3. Adobe Sign: Part of the Adobe Document Cloud suite.
4. HelloSign: A Dropbox company providing electronic signature solutions.
5. Yousign: A European electronic signature solution.
6. SignNow: Offers a user-friendly platform for electronic signatures. 
7. Zoho Sign: Integrates well with other Zoho products.
8. PandaDoc: Combines document creation with electronic signature capabilities.

These providers offer a range of solutions, from simple electronic signatures to qualified electronic signatures that meet the highest legal standards in France and the EU.

FAQ: common questions about electronic signatures in Germany

Are electronic signatures legally binding in Germany?

Yes, electronic signatures are legally binding in Germany for most contracts and legal transactions, as long as they meet the requirements set by law.

What are the different types of electronic signatures recognised in Germany?

Germany recognises three types of electronic signatures: simple electronic signature, advanced electronic signature, and qualified electronic signature.

What's the difference between simple, advanced, and qualified electronic signatures?

Simple electronic signatures are basic digital marks. Advanced electronic signatures offer more security features. Qualified electronic signatures provide the highest level of security and are legally equivalent to handwritten signatures.

Can I use an electronic signature for all documents in Germany?

While electronic signatures are widely accepted, some documents still require handwritten signatures or notarization, for instance, wills and documents related to family law.

Do I need special software to create a legally valid electronic signature in Germany?

Not necessarily for simple electronic signatures. However, for advanced or qualified electronic signatures, you'll need to use certified providers or technologies that meet legal requirements.

Are electronic signatures widely used in Germany?

Yes, electronic signatures are widely used in Germany, with significant adoption across various industries, driven by legal recognition and technological advancements.

Are there industry-specific regulations for electronic signatures in Germany?

Yes, certain industries, such as finance and healthcare have specific regulations governing the use of electronic signatures to ensure compliance and security.

Are electronic signatures from other EU countries valid in Germany?

Yes, under the eIDAS Regulation, electronic signatures issued in other EU countries are generally recognised in Germany, provided they meet the required standards.

How can I ensure that my electronic signature is legally binding in Germany?

To ensure your electronic signature is legally binding, use a certified trust service provider, comply with eIDAS standards, and choose the appropriate type of signature based on the specific contract requirements.

Who are the leading providers of electronic signature services in Germany? 

Leading providers include Juro, DocuSign, Adobe Sign, HelloSign, and others, offering diverse solutions for businesses and individuals.

--

Electronic signatures have become a vital tool for businesses and consumers in Germany, offering a secure and efficient way to sign documents electronically. The robust legal framework, driven by the eIDAS Regulation and German laws, ensures that electronic signatures are legally binding and recognised across the European Union. As technology continues to evolve and new regulations emerge, electronic signatures will play an increasingly important role in facilitating digital transactions and enhancing business efficiency.

Juro is not a law firm and this article should not be relied on as legal advice.